Boxcar Barney`s in Mayville

Boxcar Barney`s in Mayville
4.5 / 5
50 reviews

13 W Lake Rd, Mayville, NY 14757-9695, Mayville

Overview

Cuisine
  • American
Features
  • Takeout
  • Outdoor Seating
  • Wheelchair Accessible
Good for
  • Families witd children
  • Kids

Restaurant Hours

Monday

08:00 - 17:00

Tuesday

08:00 - 17:00

Wednesday

08:00 - 17:00

Thursday

00:00 - 17:00

Friday

00:00 - 17:00

Do they make their own ice cream

I don't think so but not 100% sure

Can you get lactose free ice cream here?

I believe they have sherbert.

Review

Add rating restaurant:
Boxcar Barney`s
LH
Lyle Holland
google
11.23.2024
5/5

Small cone more than you can eat.

Boxcar Barney`s
JS
Jeff Sherwood
google
10.23.2018
5/5

Amazing ice cream and they give you huge amounts!

Boxcar Barney`s
SR
Shriradha Rosie Geigerman
google
10.20.2018
5/5

Awesome flavors, huge portions!!!

Boxcar Barney`s
WB
Wanda Bystron
google
10.02.2018
5/5

Great ending to a beautiful day. Ice cream was delish and H u g e. I will have to ask for a small next time, or skip dinner....lol

Boxcar Barney`s
LH
Lou Hays
google
09.03.2018
5/5

Great selection of high quality ice cream with copious portions. An excellent outing for the whole family.

Boxcar Barney`s
ET
Eileen Thomas
google
08.13.2018
5/5

The best place to get ice cream!

Boxcar Barney`s
SM
Sarah Morgan
google
08.09.2018
5/5

Great place for a cone or a shake. Near the park and the dog park for a nice walk.

Boxcar Barney`s
ar
alena ramirez
google
08.07.2018
3/5

Great flavors but you have to get there at a decent time because there will be a line that extends halfway to the road. No restrooms

Boxcar Barney`s
TJ
Thomas Jordan
google
07.26.2018
5/5

Great place wish their season was longer

Boxcar Barney`s
hg
hank grosel
google
07.17.2018
5/5

Great ice cream, generous portions, great service, very friendly people, frozen yogurt, chocolate & vanilla&cherrydoft serve. Lots of hard serve flavors. Nice sandwich selection. Plenty of parking. Line moves quickly. Take credit cards. (October, 2018)Went today 7/20/2019 again. Line moved quickly. Still great soft serve. Portions still generous. Still my favorite ice cream place in the area.

Boxcar Barney`s
MS
Montica Seekings
google
07.05.2018
5/5

Omg amazing and delightful icecream and much more

Boxcar Barney`s
CA
Chad Anderson
google
06.05.2018
5/5

Fun, monster portions

Boxcar Barney`s
MR
Michael Roberts
google
04.25.2018
5/5

We all ordered smalls. That is more than enough. The portions are huge...

Boxcar Barney`s
DM
Daniel Madson
google
04.07.2018
5/5

The portions are massive for the price. I ordered a baby size ice cream cone and it was gigantic! I think all of there ice cream is homemade as well, which is a nice change from all the chain ice cream places that all carry Perry's. Brownie batter and orange creamsicle were our choices and they were so good. It was a nice treat on a hot summer day.

Boxcar Barney`s
ddup2727
google
01.07.2018
5/5

This place has the best ice cream in three states. I had heard rumors but wow. The menu is expansive three ice cream is awesome. Great vibe too. Can't wait to get back.

Boxcar Barney`s
AC
Ariel Cartwright
google
11.18.2017
5/5

Boxcar Barney's hasn't seen better days! This ice cream/sandwich shop has undergone a wonderful transformation this season. The building has been cleaned up, the tables are all new, there are beautiful potted plants brightening up the space, they play modern music, and the menu has been revised. They offer more ice cream choices than I have ever seen offered at any ice cream shop I've ever visited and their portions are very generous (I would suggest ordering a baby size or a small, anything larger might be too much to finish). They have even added a space to play corn hole; I thought that was a clever addition. For anyone who hasn't eaten at Barney's before, I think you'll really enjoy the view of the lake while you eat right at Barney's, or it's just a short walk to the Lakeside Park across the street.

Boxcar Barney`s
NK
Natalie Kindler
google
11.01.2017
5/5

Delicious ice cream place close to Chautauqua Institution. Highly recommend the Heavenly Hazelnut and Salted Caramel flavors! Soooo tasty!

Boxcar Barney`s
aidenjamesstarks
google
10.22.2017
1/5

I dont like it it is bad

Boxcar Barney`s
PT
Paula Tully
google
10.21.2017
5/5

The ice cream was delicious, prices fair, and sizes BIG. The only downside was the time it took for the line to move.

Boxcar Barney`s
SD
Susan D.
google
08.19.2017
5/5

Loved this place! They offer hard ice cream plus soft serve including frozen yogurt. Waffle cones were delicious. Portions were enormous. Everything was top quality and service was great!

Boxcar Barney`s
SS
Simone S
google
08.03.2017
5/5

Delicious! Huge servings!

Boxcar Barney`s
KH
Kim H
google
05.25.2017
5/5

Excellent ice cream, enjoyed 4 ice cream sampler selection! Nice spot across from Lake Chataqua & a kid's park.

Boxcar Barney`s
Kk
Kristin kioko
google
03.13.2017
5/5

There is a reason that the line is so long! LOVE the soft serve! The wait is insignificant compared to the amazing yumminess. The face-lift is wonderful too. Bring your friends and hang out for awhile! You won't regret it.

Boxcar Barney`s
RR
Robbie Reid
google
03.12.2017
5/5

We where in Ripley New York for the day to see family. Was looking for the Icecream place that we found last time by chance in 2016. Couldn't find it again, but with a quick search we found this wonderful gem in the most Picturesque town.

Boxcar Barney`s
AquaGames
google
02.22.2017
5/5

The place has good ice cream and shakes!

Boxcar Barney`s
KO
Kelly O'Donnell
google
01.12.2017
5/5

Best ice cream stop around!

Boxcar Barney`s
SS
Sarah Smonskey
google
11.11.2016
5/5

Delicious. Love the Coconut (with chocolate and almonds)... Serving sizes are very large for the price.

Boxcar Barney`s
RS
Raymond Seebald
google
11.03.2016
5/5

You have to stop here for ice cream if not to have one just to see what a large looks like. They are gigantic! I wonder how they make any money. All fresh and delicious ice cream. A summer favorite.

Boxcar Barney`s
AB
Andy Brown
google
10.21.2016
5/5

Great ice cream! Good sizes and good prices. We were driving by a saw a line of people waiting for ice cream. That was a pretty good indicator it was a local favorite. We were not disappointed at all.

Boxcar Barney`s
SS
Sarah Shaffer
google
10.17.2016
5/5

Baby cones are huge. Love coming with the family and splitting a flight. Friendly staff and yummy flavors. My favorite is cookie dough.

Boxcar Barney`s
T
google
10.16.2016
5/5

Biggest ice cream around!! We drive 20 minutes to go here. Love the revamp and that they take debit/credit now. Keep up the revamp it's looking great! Our favorite thing is to get ice cream and either go to the big playground across the street on the lake or walk the rails to trails trail that starts right behind boxcar's. It's well maintained and great for strollers and littles.

Boxcar Barney`s
SC
Sharon Comi
google
10.11.2016
5/5

Best ice cream I have ever eaten! Sizes are very large and prices are very low! ❤️

Boxcar Barney`s
SB
Sarah Blakeslee Horton
google
10.09.2016
5/5

Awesome flavors sizes and prices. Fast and friendly staff and service. So worth it!!!!

Boxcar Barney`s
mH
mick H
google
10.01.2016
4/5

Awesome ice cream 🍦 🍨 and Big

Boxcar Barney`s
LC
Laurie Capozzi
google
09.21.2016
3/5

I counted 50 people in line. That tells me you need more employee's. New owner, new prices ...Nobody should have to wait in a line like that. Have some consideration for your customers!

Boxcar Barney`s
KM
Katelyn McClinton
google
08.27.2016
5/5

OMG! The variety of flavors this place has! Absolutely amazing! And the quality of the homemade ice cream? Delicious and wonderful! Just be warned, the serving sizes are huge, so if you are unsure of how much ice cream you'd like, go smaller. If you want ice cream by Chautauqua lake, this is DEFINITELY the place to go!!!

Boxcar Barney`s
staticbird11
google
08.16.2016
5/5

Very large portions. Ice cream/ shakes/ desserts only. My photo is of the "baby" sized cone. It was plenty!

Boxcar Barney`s
ES
Emil Stavinoha
google
08.08.2016
5/5

Probably the best strawberry ice cream I've ever had. Other flavors are great too.

Boxcar Barney`s
TK
Timmy K
google
07.27.2016
5/5

The size of the portions of their ice cream is huge! Priced very reasonably as well. The lines can get long during peak times so plan accordingly and cut the staff some slack as they're working as hard as they can inside a small area to satisfy everyone's needs.

Boxcar Barney`s
MH
Marilyn Hicks
google
07.10.2016
4/5

Friendly easy to find great ice cream

Boxcar Barney`s
BR
Bob Rogers
google
06.23.2016
5/5

Busiest ice cream store ever, well worth the wait. Always happy with just the "small" size.

Boxcar Barney`s
TH
Tim Hallmark
google
05.19.2016
4/5

Great place

Boxcar Barney`s
AB
Angela Barrett
google
05.15.2016
5/5

Great ice cream. Seating is limited and not a lot of places to seat as it fills up quickly. Decent prices. Spent $26 for a family of 6

Boxcar Barney`s
SM
Stephen Moon
google
03.20.2016
5/5

Serving sizes are huge, and it's good ice cream. Enough said.

Boxcar Barney`s
TB
Thomas Bozer
google
03.08.2016
5/5

The need and location of this ice cream / soft serve stand is A # 1. The flavors and serving sizes are crazy good.

Boxcar Barney`s
CA
Chris A
google
03.03.2016
5/5

Great ice cream with very larger portions so order smaller than usual.

Boxcar Barney`s
DJ
Daviyion Johnson
google
02.24.2016
5/5

Went here while on vacation in the area and I was not disappointed. Friendly staff and quick service. Lots of delicious flavors to choose and including some fun ones. I had the 'baby' cone ($3.78) and that thing was massive so I can only imagine what larger sizes looked like, but this was perfect for me. I had the Moose Tracks and Brownie Batter and they were both amazing!If you're near chautauqua lake, I definitely recommend checking this place out.

Boxcar Barney`s
HB
Hillary Bevens
google
02.19.2016
5/5

Great ice cream and phenomenal customer service. We had a peanut allergy in our group and they went above and beyond to keep our flight safe for her to eat!

Boxcar Barney`s
TW
Travis Weise
google
02.04.2016
5/5

Amazing ice cream. Sizes are big so bring your appetite

Boxcar Barney`s
VB
Vicki Bradigan
google
01.08.2016
5/5

OMG took 3 of my grandsons, a small was HUGE. Not knowing ordered Medium for older boys, had to get cups 1/2 way into eating. WOW.

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Order food

Reservation

Want to order over the phone?

Call 17167533778

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!